回主页
天涯知识库 · 品人录
目录
位置: > 古代文学 > 古代兵书 > 品人录 >

项羽:二、项羽的毛病

其实,项羽的病还远不止于此。

韩信离开项羽投奔刘邦后,曾与刘邦有一次长谈,谈话的内容主要是谈项羽。刘邦问韩信,萧丞相一而再、再而三地向寡人推荐将军,请问将军有什么计策教导寡人呢?韩信并不直接回答这个问题,却反问:如今与大王东向争权天下的,岂非就是项王?刘邦说是。韩信又问:大王自己掂量掂量,如果论个人的勇猛和兵势的强,您比得上项王吗?刘邦默然良久,说:我不如他。韩信起身一拜说,这就对了。便是我韩信,也认为大王不如他。这就奇怪。明知刘邦比不过项羽,却要背叛了项羽来投奔刘邦,岂不是犯傻?韩信当然不傻。他向刘邦透彻地分析了项羽的为人,分析了项羽必然会失败的心理和格上的原因。依照韩信的说法,项羽至少有两条致命的弱点,即“匹夫之勇”和“妇人之仁”。但在我看来,根据这一谈话,还起码得再加两条,即“小家子气”和“小心眼儿”。

先说“匹夫之勇”。

项羽这个人,应该说是很勇敢的。他这辈子,似乎没怕过什么,只有别人怕他。他的身体也好。《史记》说他“长八尺余,力能扛鼎”,可以想见其英武魁伟、肌肉发达、孔武有力。

公元前207年,赵王君臣被秦兵围在巨鹿,告急的羽书雪片般飞来。当时救赵的诸侯之兵凡十余壁(营垒),却无不做壁上观,只有项羽率楚军破釜沉舟,一以当十,与秦军血战九次,动天的杀声把诸侯将士的脸都吓白了,这才大破秦军,救出赵王。有这样的胆量,又有这样的体格,项羽便觉得如果不让它们有用武之地,实在是一种费,可惜了的。所以项羽便常常要逞威逞武。他虽然是主帅,却喜欢冲锋陷阵。每次战斗,都身先士卒,自然也都所向披。往往是,项羽的兵器还没有出手,只不过瞪眼一呵,对方便魂飞魄散,一败涂地。这样的战绩,很是不少。我相信,每来这么一回,项羽心里一定充满了快感。

这种快感甚至使他忍不住要同对方的主帅决斗。他对刘邦说,天下不得安宁这么多年,不就是因为我们两个吗?干脆我们两个打一架,谁打赢了,天下就是谁的,何必弄得天下人都跟着受罪!这真是英雄气概十足,贵族派头十足。可惜刘邦不吃这一套。他才不会和项羽单兵独练,徒手过招呢!于是刘邦咯咯直笑说,刘某斗智不斗勇。

从审美的角度看,刘邦的表现一点也不酷。但从政治学和军事学的角度看,刘邦却是对的。战争是政治的延续,是政治斗争的最高手段。战争的胜负,说到底,是政治斗争的胜负,至少也是战略战术的胜负,与主帅个人力气、身材的大小没什么关系。

谁都知道:“兵不在多而在,将不在勇而在谋”。项羽自己也不是不知道,否则他就不会去学兵法,不会说不学“一人敌”而要学“万人敌”了。可惜,事到临头,他学的“万人敌”一点也用不上,用得上的还是“一人敌”。可见项羽实非帅才,不过是一个特别霸蛮特别有力的匹夫。

匹夫之勇是一人之勇,将帅之勇是万人之勇。战场上是不能没有勇敢的,所谓“两军相敌勇者胜”。但是,这里说的勇,是全军之勇,而不是个人之勇。当然,在某些时候,将领的身先士卒,确能起到鼓舞士气的作用,在冷兵器时代就更是如此。然而,项羽的冲锋陷阵,却并不完全是为了鼓舞士气,有时也是为了自己逞能过瘾。结果,由于他过于个人英雄主义,反倒让其他将领和士兵觉得自己可有可无,哪里还会有集体的智慧和力量?司马迁批评他“奋其私智”(只靠个人),“欲以力征”(只靠暴力),两条都说到了点子上。

再说“妇人之仁”。

妇人之仁和匹夫之勇好像是矛盾的。其实项羽这个人原本就很矛盾。他的格中,有勇敢的一面,也有怯懦的一面;有残忍的一面,也有温柔的一面。项羽自称西楚霸王,事实上也够野蛮霸道的。他情暴烈,恃强沽勇,杀起人来一点都不手软。会稽郡守殷通和他前世无仇后世无冤,而且还是打算和他们合伙起义反秦的,说杀就杀了。

然而在鸿门宴上,面对刘邦,他却下不了手。

是因为刘邦与他无冤无仇吗?殷通也与他无冤无仇。是因为刘邦于他有恩有德吗?刘邦先入咸陽,已让他恨得咬牙切齿。是因为不知利害关系吗?范增已经说得非常清楚:刘邦“其志不在小”,又有“天子之气”,实在是必欲去之的心腹之患。是没有能力杀吗?以项羽之武功,叫谁三更死,谁还能活到五更?何况刘邦名为项羽座上客,实为阶下囚,里里外外都是项羽的人,连樊哙都对刘邦说现在人家是菜刀砧板,我们是鸡鸭鱼肉。是没有机会下手吗?机会多的是。至少在樊哙进帐护驾前,是没有问题的。可任凭范增又是递眼色,又是打暗号,项羽就是默然不应,终于让刘邦这只烤熟了的鸭子又飞了。气得范增恨恨地骂道:“竖子不足与谋(这小子真不配和他谋事儿)!”

其实范增早已看透:“君王有不忍之心。”所谓“不忍之心”,也就是“妇人之仁”。

但,项羽不是很残忍的吗?怎么又会“不忍”?

实际上,项羽表面上看很强硬,其实内心很脆弱。项羽是一个很面子的人。面子的人内心都很脆弱。惟其脆弱,才那么面子。因为他受不了半点伤害,这才要拼命护住自己的面子。项羽的自刎乌江,很大程度上是出于面子的考虑:“纵江东父老怜而王我,我何面目见之!”于是便留下了一句关于面子的名言:“无颜见江东父老。”为什么无颜相见呢?除心中有愧外,还因为受不了那份怜悯。对于项羽这样一个一生要强的人来说,怜悯即是伤害。因此他宁愿去死。

项羽的小家子气有时让人觉得不可思议。他占领了咸陽,却放着现成的皇帝不做,现成的帝都不住,只是烧杀掠抢一番,把金银财宝漂亮女人装满了车子,又跑回彭城(今江苏徐州)当西楚霸王去了。有人劝项羽说,关中地势险要,土地肥沃,建都于此,可定霸业。他却说,富贵了不回老家去,岂不是穿着漂亮衣服在黑夜里出行(衣锦夜行),谁看得见?这真是小家子气!

说这句话的人当场就被项羽扔到锅里煮了,但项羽的没有出息,却也几乎成了公认的事实。王伯祥先生认为,衣锦还乡的说法,不过是项羽的托辞。他的真实想法,是因为楚的根据地在江东,又放心不下楚怀王。其实,那个有名无实的傀儡楚王、项羽自己扶上台的放羊娃子又何足挂齿?

这就是小心眼儿了。正是这小心眼儿,使他谋杀怀王,从而失去人心。也正是这小心眼儿,使他疑心范增,从而失去臂膀。小家子气已让人看不起,小心眼儿更让人受不了。于是,他身边那些有能力有志向的人如韩信、陈平便一个个都离他而去,只剩下一匹骏马一个美人和他心心相印。

项羽的孤独,是他自己造成的。项羽的失败,也是他自己造成的。

推荐阅读

孙子兵法> 孙子兵法翻译> 孙膑兵法> 孙膑兵法> 纪效新书> 李卫公问对> 三略译文> 吴子兵法> 冰鉴译文> 草庐经略>

阅读分类导航

唐诗四大文学名著宋词诸子百家史书古代医书蒙学易经书籍古代兵书古典侠义小说
Weibo Article 1 Weibo Article 2 Weibo Article 3 Weibo Article 4 Weibo Article 5 Weibo Article 6 Weibo Article 7 Weibo Article 8 Weibo Article 9 Weibo Article 10 Weibo Article 11 Weibo Article 12 Weibo Article 13 Weibo Article 14 Weibo Article 15 Weibo Article 16 Weibo Article 17 Weibo Article 18 Weibo Article 19 Weibo Article 20 Weibo Article 21 Weibo Article 22 Weibo Article 23 Weibo Article 24 Weibo Article 25 Weibo Article 26 Weibo Article 27 Weibo Article 28 Weibo Article 29 Weibo Article 30 Weibo Article 31 Weibo Article 32 Weibo Article 33 Weibo Article 34 Weibo Article 35 Weibo Article 36 Weibo Article 37 Weibo Article 38 Weibo Article 39 Weibo Article 40 Weibo Article 41 Weibo Article 42 Weibo Article 43 Weibo Article 44 Weibo Article 45 Weibo Article 46 Weibo Article 47 Weibo Article 48 Weibo Article 49 Weibo Article 50 Weibo Article 51 Weibo Article 52 Weibo Article 53 Weibo Article 54 Weibo Article 55 Weibo Article 56 Weibo Article 57 Weibo Article 58 Weibo Article 59 Weibo Article 60 Weibo Article 61 Weibo Article 62 Weibo Article 63 Weibo Article 64 Weibo Article 65 Weibo Article 66 Weibo Article 67 Weibo Article 68 Weibo Article 69 Weibo Article 70 Weibo Article 71 Weibo Article 72 Weibo Article 73 Weibo Article 74 Weibo Article 75 Weibo Article 76 Weibo Article 77 Weibo Article 78 Weibo Article 79 Weibo Article 80 Weibo Article 81 Weibo Article 82 Weibo Article 83 Weibo Article 84 Weibo Article 85 Weibo Article 86 Weibo Article 87 Weibo Article 88 Weibo Article 89 Weibo Article 90 Weibo Article 91 Weibo Article 92 Weibo Article 93 Weibo Article 94 Weibo Article 95 Weibo Article 96 Weibo Article 97 Weibo Article 98 Weibo Article 99 Weibo Article 100 Weibo Article 101 Weibo Article 102 Weibo Article 103 Weibo Article 104 Weibo Article 105 Weibo Article 106 Weibo Article 107 Weibo Article 108 Weibo Article 109 Weibo Article 110 Weibo Article 111 Weibo Article 112 Weibo Article 113 Weibo Article 114 Weibo Article 115 Weibo Article 116 Weibo Article 117 Weibo Article 118 Weibo Article 119 Weibo Article 120 Weibo Article 121 Weibo Article 122 Weibo Article 123 Weibo Article 124 Weibo Article 125 Weibo Article 126 Weibo Article 127 Weibo Article 128 Weibo Article 129 Weibo Article 130 Weibo Article 131 Weibo Article 132 Weibo Article 133 Weibo Article 134 Weibo Article 135 Weibo Article 136 Weibo Article 137 Weibo Article 138 Weibo Article 139 Weibo Article 140 Weibo Article 141 Weibo Article 142 Weibo Article 143 Weibo Article 144 Weibo Article 145 Weibo Article 146 Weibo Article 147 Weibo Article 148 Weibo Article 149 Weibo Article 150 Weibo Article 151 Weibo Article 152 Weibo Article 153 Weibo Article 154 Weibo Article 155 Weibo Article 156 Weibo Article 157 Weibo Article 158 Weibo Article 159 Weibo Article 160 Weibo Article 161 Weibo Article 162 Weibo Article 163 Weibo Article 164 Weibo Article 165 Weibo Article 166 Weibo Article 167 Weibo Article 168 Weibo Article 169 Weibo Article 170 Weibo Article 171 Weibo Article 172 Weibo Article 173 Weibo Article 174 Weibo Article 175 Weibo Article 176 Weibo Article 177 Weibo Article 178 Weibo Article 179 Weibo Article 180 Weibo Article 181 Weibo Article 182 Weibo Article 183 Weibo Article 184 Weibo Article 185 Weibo Article 186 Weibo Article 187 Weibo Article 188 Weibo Article 189 Weibo Article 190 Weibo Article 191 Weibo Article 192 Weibo Article 193 Weibo Article 194 Weibo Article 195 Weibo Article 196 Weibo Article 197 Weibo Article 198 Weibo Article 199 Weibo Article 200 Weibo Article 201 Weibo Article 202 Weibo Article 203 Weibo Article 204 Weibo Article 205 Weibo Article 206 Weibo Article 207 Weibo Article 208 Weibo Article 209 Weibo Article 210 Weibo Article 211 Weibo Article 212 Weibo Article 213 Weibo Article 214 Weibo Article 215 Weibo Article 216 Weibo Article 217 Weibo Article 218 Weibo Article 219 Weibo Article 220 Weibo Article 221 Weibo Article 222 Weibo Article 223 Weibo Article 224 Weibo Article 225 Weibo Article 226 Weibo Article 227 Weibo Article 228 Weibo Article 229 Weibo Article 230 Weibo Article 231 Weibo Article 232 Weibo Article 233 Weibo Article 234 Weibo Article 235 Weibo Article 236 Weibo Article 237 Weibo Article 238 Weibo Article 239 Weibo Article 240 Weibo Article 241 Weibo Article 242 Weibo Article 243 Weibo Article 244 Weibo Article 245 Weibo Article 246 Weibo Article 247 Weibo Article 248 Weibo Article 249 Weibo Article 250 Weibo Article 251 Weibo Article 252 Weibo Article 253 Weibo Article 254 Weibo Article 255 Weibo Article 256 Weibo Article 257 Weibo Article 258 Weibo Article 259 Weibo Article 260 Weibo Article 261 Weibo Article 262 Weibo Article 263 Weibo Article 264 Weibo Article 265 Weibo Article 266 Weibo Article 267 Weibo Article 268 Weibo Article 269 Weibo Article 270 Weibo Article 271 Weibo Article 272 Weibo Article 273 Weibo Article 274 Weibo Article 275 Weibo Article 276 Weibo Article 277 Weibo Article 278 Weibo Article 279 Weibo Article 280 Weibo Article 281 Weibo Article 282 Weibo Article 283 Weibo Article 284 Weibo Article 285 Weibo Article 286 Weibo Article 287 Weibo Article 288 Weibo Article 289 Weibo Article 290 Weibo Article 291 Weibo Article 292 Weibo Article 293 Weibo Article 294 Weibo Article 295 Weibo Article 296 Weibo Article 297 Weibo Article 298 Weibo Article 299 Weibo Article 300 Weibo Article 301 Weibo Article 302 Weibo Article 303 Weibo Article 304 Weibo Article 305 Weibo Article 306 Weibo Article 307 Weibo Article 308 Weibo Article 309 Weibo Article 310 Weibo Article 311 Weibo Article 312 Weibo Article 313 Weibo Article 314 Weibo Article 315 Weibo Article 316 Weibo Article 317 Weibo Article 318 Weibo Article 319 Weibo Article 320 Weibo Article 321 Weibo Article 322 Weibo Article 323 Weibo Article 324 Weibo Article 325 Weibo Article 326 Weibo Article 327 Weibo Article 328 Weibo Article 329 Weibo Article 330 Weibo Article 331 Weibo Article 332 Weibo Article 333 Weibo Article 334 Weibo Article 335 Weibo Article 336 Weibo Article 337 Weibo Article 338 Weibo Article 339 Weibo Article 340 Weibo Article 341 Weibo Article 342 Weibo Article 343 Weibo Article 344 Weibo Article 345 Weibo Article 346 Weibo Article 347 Weibo Article 348 Weibo Article 349 Weibo Article 350 Weibo Article 351 Weibo Article 352 Weibo Article 353 Weibo Article 354 Weibo Article 355 Weibo Article 356 Weibo Article 357 Weibo Article 358 Weibo Article 359 Weibo Article 360 Weibo Article 361 Weibo Article 362 Weibo Article 363 Weibo Article 364 Weibo Article 365 Weibo Article 366 Weibo Article 367 Weibo Article 368 Weibo Article 369 Weibo Article 370 Weibo Article 371 Weibo Article 372 Weibo Article 373 Weibo Article 374 Weibo Article 375 Weibo Article 376 Weibo Article 377 Weibo Article 378 Weibo Article 379 Weibo Article 380 Weibo Article 381 Weibo Article 382 Weibo Article 383 Weibo Article 384 Weibo Article 385 Weibo Article 386 Weibo Article 387 Weibo Article 388 Weibo Article 389 Weibo Article 390 Weibo Article 391 Weibo Article 392 Weibo Article 393 Weibo Article 394 Weibo Article 395 Weibo Article 396 Weibo Article 397 Weibo Article 398 Weibo Article 399 Weibo Article 400 Weibo Article 401 Weibo Article 402 Weibo Article 403 Weibo Article 404 Weibo Article 405 Weibo Article 406 Weibo Article 407 Weibo Article 408 Weibo Article 409 Weibo Article 410 Weibo Article 411 Weibo Article 412 Weibo Article 413 Weibo Article 414 Weibo Article 415 Weibo Article 416 Weibo Article 417 Weibo Article 418 Weibo Article 419 Weibo Article 420 Weibo Article 421 Weibo Article 422 Weibo Article 423 Weibo Article 424 Weibo Article 425 Weibo Article 426 Weibo Article 427 Weibo Article 428 Weibo Article 429 Weibo Article 430 Weibo Article 431 Weibo Article 432 Weibo Article 433 Weibo Article 434 Weibo Article 435 Weibo Article 436 Weibo Article 437 Weibo Article 438 Weibo Article 439 Weibo Article 440 Weibo Article 441 Weibo Article 442 Weibo Article 443 Weibo Article 444 Weibo Article 445 Weibo Article 446 Weibo Article 447 Weibo Article 448 Weibo Article 449 Weibo Article 450 Weibo Article 451 Weibo Article 452 Weibo Article 453 Weibo Article 454 Weibo Article 455 Weibo Article 456 Weibo Article 457 Weibo Article 458 Weibo Article 459 Weibo Article 460 Weibo Article 461 Weibo Article 462 Weibo Article 463 Weibo Article 464 Weibo Article 465 Weibo Article 466 Weibo Article 467 Weibo Article 468 Weibo Article 469 Weibo Article 470 Weibo Article 471 Weibo Article 472 Weibo Article 473 Weibo Article 474 Weibo Article 475 Weibo Article 476 Weibo Article 477 Weibo Article 478 Weibo Article 479 Weibo Article 480 Weibo Article 481 Weibo Article 482 Weibo Article 483 Weibo Article 484 Weibo Article 485 Weibo Article 486 Weibo Article 487 Weibo Article 488 Weibo Article 489 Weibo Article 490 Weibo Article 491 Weibo Article 492 Weibo Article 493 Weibo Article 494 Weibo Article 495 Weibo Article 496 Weibo Article 497 Weibo Article 498 Weibo Article 499 Weibo Article 500 Weibo Article 501 Weibo Article 502 Weibo Article 503 Weibo Article 504 Weibo Article 505 Weibo Article 506 Weibo Article 507 Weibo Article 508 Weibo Article 509 Weibo Article 510 Weibo Article 511 Weibo Article 512 Weibo Article 513 Weibo Article 514 Weibo Article 515 Weibo Article 516 Weibo Article 517 Weibo Article 518 Weibo Article 519 Weibo Article 520 Weibo Article 521 Weibo Article 522 Weibo Article 523 Weibo Article 524 Weibo Article 525 Weibo Article 526 Weibo Article 527 Weibo Article 528 Weibo Article 529 Weibo Article 530 Weibo Article 531 Weibo Article 532 Weibo Article 533 Weibo Article 534 Weibo Article 535 Weibo Article 536 Weibo Article 537 Weibo Article 538 Weibo Article 539 Weibo Article 540 Weibo Article 541 Weibo Article 542 Weibo Article 543 Weibo Article 544 Weibo Article 545 Weibo Article 546 Weibo Article 547 Weibo Article 548 Weibo Article 549 Weibo Article 550 Weibo Article 551 Weibo Article 552 Weibo Article 553 Weibo Article 554 Weibo Article 555 Weibo Article 556 Weibo Article 557 Weibo Article 558 Weibo Article 559 Weibo Article 560 Weibo Article 561 Weibo Article 562 Weibo Article 563 Weibo Article 564 Weibo Article 565 Weibo Article 566 Weibo Article 567 Weibo Article 568 Weibo Article 569 Weibo Article 570 Weibo Article 571 Weibo Article 572 Weibo Article 573 Weibo Article 574 Weibo Article 575 Weibo Article 576 Weibo Article 577 Weibo Article 578 Weibo Article 579 Weibo Article 580 Weibo Article 581 Weibo Article 582 Weibo Article 583 Weibo Article 584 Weibo Article 585 Weibo Article 586 Weibo Article 587 Weibo Article 588 Weibo Article 589 Weibo Article 590 Weibo Article 591 Weibo Article 592 Weibo Article 593 Weibo Article 594 Weibo Article 595 Weibo Article 596 Weibo Article 597 Weibo Article 598 Weibo Article 599 Weibo Article 600 Weibo Article 601 Weibo Article 602 Weibo Article 603 Weibo Article 604 Weibo Article 605 Weibo Article 606 Weibo Article 607 Weibo Article 608 Weibo Article 609 Weibo Article 610 Weibo Article 611 Weibo Article 612 Weibo Article 613 Weibo Article 614 Weibo Article 615 Weibo Article 616 Weibo Article 617 Weibo Article 618 Weibo Article 619 Weibo Article 620 Weibo Article 621 Weibo Article 622 Weibo Article 623 Weibo Article 624 Weibo Article 625 Weibo Article 626 Weibo Article 627 Weibo Article 628 Weibo Article 629 Weibo Article 630 Weibo Article 631 Weibo Article 632 Weibo Article 633 Weibo Article 634 Weibo Article 635 Weibo Article 636 Weibo Article 637 Weibo Article 638 Weibo Article 639 Weibo Article 640 Weibo Article 641 Weibo Article 642 Weibo Article 643 Weibo Article 644 Weibo Article 645 Weibo Article 646 Weibo Article 647 Weibo Article 648 Weibo Article 649 Weibo Article 650 Weibo Article 651 Weibo Article 652 Weibo Article 653 Weibo Article 654 Weibo Article 655 Weibo Article 656 Weibo Article 657 Weibo Article 658 Weibo Article 659 Weibo Article 660 Weibo Article 661 Weibo Article 662 Weibo Article 663 Weibo Article 664 Weibo Article 665 Weibo Article 666 Weibo Article 667 Weibo Article 668 Weibo Article 669 Weibo Article 670 Weibo Article 671 Weibo Article 672 Weibo Article 673 Weibo Article 674 Weibo Article 675 Weibo Article 676 Weibo Article 677 Weibo Article 678 Weibo Article 679 Weibo Article 680 Weibo Article 681 Weibo Article 682 Weibo Article 683 Weibo Article 684 Weibo Article 685 Weibo Article 686 Weibo Article 687 Weibo Article 688 Weibo Article 689 Weibo Article 690 Weibo Article 691 Weibo Article 692 Weibo Article 693 Weibo Article 694 Weibo Article 695 Weibo Article 696 Weibo Article 697 Weibo Article 698 Weibo Article 699 Weibo Article 700 Weibo Article 701 Weibo Article 702 Weibo Article 703 Weibo Article 704 Weibo Article 705 Weibo Article 706 Weibo Article 707 Weibo Article 708 Weibo Article 709 Weibo Article 710 Weibo Article 711 Weibo Article 712 Weibo Article 713 Weibo Article 714 Weibo Article 715 Weibo Article 716 Weibo Article 717 Weibo Article 718 Weibo Article 719 Weibo Article 720 Weibo Article 721 Weibo Article 722 Weibo Article 723 Weibo Article 724 Weibo Article 725 Weibo Article 726 Weibo Article 727 Weibo Article 728 Weibo Article 729 Weibo Article 730 Weibo Article 731 Weibo Article 732 Weibo Article 733 Weibo Article 734 Weibo Article 735 Weibo Article 736 Weibo Article 737 Weibo Article 738 Weibo Article 739 Weibo Article 740 Weibo Article 741 Weibo Article 742 Weibo Article 743 Weibo Article 744 Weibo Article 745 Weibo Article 746 Weibo Article 747 Weibo Article 748 Weibo Article 749 Weibo Article 750 Weibo Article 751 Weibo Article 752 Weibo Article 753 Weibo Article 754 Weibo Article 755 Weibo Article 756 Weibo Article 757 Weibo Article 758 Weibo Article 759 Weibo Article 760 Weibo Article 761 Weibo Article 762 Weibo Article 763 Weibo Article 764 Weibo Article 765 Weibo Article 766 Weibo Article 767 Weibo Article 768 Weibo Article 769 Weibo Article 770 Weibo Article 771 Weibo Article 772 Weibo Article 773 Weibo Article 774 Weibo Article 775 Weibo Article 776 Weibo Article 777 Weibo Article 778 Weibo Article 779 Weibo Article 780 Weibo Article 781 Weibo Article 782 Weibo Article 783 Weibo Article 784 Weibo Article 785 Weibo Article 786 Weibo Article 787 Weibo Article 788 Weibo Article 789 Weibo Article 790 Weibo Article 791 Weibo Article 792 Weibo Article 793 Weibo Article 794 Weibo Article 795 Weibo Article 796 Weibo Article 797 Weibo Article 798 Weibo Article 799 Weibo Article 800 Weibo Article 801 Weibo Article 802 Weibo Article 803 Weibo Article 804 Weibo Article 805 Weibo Article 806 Weibo Article 807 Weibo Article 808 Weibo Article 809 Weibo Article 810 Weibo Article 811 Weibo Article 812 Weibo Article 813 Weibo Article 814 Weibo Article 815 Weibo Article 816 Weibo Article 817 Weibo Article 818 Weibo Article 819 Weibo Article 820 Weibo Article 821 Weibo Article 822 Weibo Article 823 Weibo Article 824 Weibo Article 825 Weibo Article 826 Weibo Article 827 Weibo Article 828 Weibo Article 829 Weibo Article 830 Weibo Article 831 Weibo Article 832 Weibo Article 833 Weibo Article 834 Weibo Article 835 Weibo Article 836 Weibo Article 837 Weibo Article 838 Weibo Article 839 Weibo Article 840 Weibo Article 841 Weibo Article 842 Weibo Article 843 Weibo Article 844 Weibo Article 845 Weibo Article 846 Weibo Article 847 Weibo Article 848 Weibo Article 849 Weibo Article 850 Weibo Article 851 Weibo Article 852 Weibo Article 853 Weibo Article 854 Weibo Article 855 Weibo Article 856 Weibo Article 857 Weibo Article 858 Weibo Article 859 Weibo Article 860 Weibo Article 861 Weibo Article 862 Weibo Article 863 Weibo Article 864 Weibo Article 865 Weibo Article 866 Weibo Article 867 Weibo Article 868 Weibo Article 869 Weibo Article 870 Weibo Article 871 Weibo Article 872 Weibo Article 873 Weibo Article 874 Weibo Article 875 Weibo Article 876 Weibo Article 877 Weibo Article 878 Weibo Article 879 Weibo Article 880 Weibo Article 881 Weibo Article 882 Weibo Article 883 Weibo Article 884 Weibo Article 885 Weibo Article 886 Weibo Article 887 Weibo Article 888 Weibo Article 889 Weibo Article 890 Weibo Article 891 Weibo Article 892 Weibo Article 893 Weibo Article 894 Weibo Article 895 Weibo Article 896 Weibo Article 897 Weibo Article 898 Weibo Article 899 Weibo Article 900 Weibo Article 901 Weibo Article 902 Weibo Article 903 Weibo Article 904 Weibo Article 905 Weibo Article 906 Weibo Article 907 Weibo Article 908 Weibo Article 909 Weibo Article 910 Weibo Article 911 Weibo Article 912 Weibo Article 913 Weibo Article 914 Weibo Article 915 Weibo Article 916 Weibo Article 917 Weibo Article 918 Weibo Article 919 Weibo Article 920 Weibo Article 921 Weibo Article 922 Weibo Article 923 Weibo Article 924 Weibo Article 925 Weibo Article 926 Weibo Article 927 Weibo Article 928 Weibo Article 929 Weibo Article 930 Weibo Article 931 Weibo Article 932 Weibo Article 933 Weibo Article 934 Weibo Article 935 Weibo Article 936 Weibo Article 937 Weibo Article 938 Weibo Article 939 Weibo Article 940 Weibo Article 941 Weibo Article 942 Weibo Article 943 Weibo Article 944 Weibo Article 945 Weibo Article 946 Weibo Article 947 Weibo Article 948 Weibo Article 949 Weibo Article 950 Weibo Article 951 Weibo Article 952 Weibo Article 953 Weibo Article 954 Weibo Article 955 Weibo Article 956 Weibo Article 957 Weibo Article 958 Weibo Article 959 Weibo Article 960 Weibo Article 961 Weibo Article 962 Weibo Article 963 Weibo Article 964 Weibo Article 965 Weibo Article 966 Weibo Article 967 Weibo Article 968 Weibo Article 969 Weibo Article 970 Weibo Article 971 Weibo Article 972 Weibo Article 973 Weibo Article 974 Weibo Article 975 Weibo Article 976 Weibo Article 977 Weibo Article 978 Weibo Article 979 Weibo Article 980 Weibo Article 981 Weibo Article 982 Weibo Article 983 Weibo Article 984 Weibo Article 985 Weibo Article 986 Weibo Article 987 Weibo Article 988 Weibo Article 989 Weibo Article 990 Weibo Article 991 Weibo Article 992 Weibo Article 993 Weibo Article 994 Weibo Article 995 Weibo Article 996 Weibo Article 997 Weibo Article 998 Weibo Article 999 Weibo Article 1000 Weibo Article 1001 Weibo Article 1002 Weibo Article 1003 Weibo Article 1004 Weibo Article 1005 Weibo Article 1006 Weibo Article 1007 Weibo Article 1008 Weibo Article 1009 Weibo Article 1010 Weibo Article 1011 Weibo Article 1012 Weibo Article 1013 Weibo Article 1014 Weibo Article 1015 Weibo Article 1016 Weibo Article 1017 Weibo Article 1018 Weibo Article 1019 Weibo Article 1020 Weibo Article 1021 Weibo Article 1022 Weibo Article 1023 Weibo Article 1024 Weibo Article 1025 Weibo Article 1026 Weibo Article 1027 Weibo Article 1028 Weibo Article 1029 Weibo Article 1030 Weibo Article 1031 Weibo Article 1032 Weibo Article 1033 Weibo Article 1034 Weibo Article 1035 Weibo Article 1036 Weibo Article 1037 Weibo Article 1038 Weibo Article 1039 Weibo Article 1040 Weibo Article 1041 Weibo Article 1042 Weibo Article 1043 Weibo Article 1044 Weibo Article 1045 Weibo Article 1046 Weibo Article 1047 Weibo Article 1048 Weibo Article 1049 Weibo Article 1050 Weibo Article 1051 Weibo Article 1052 Weibo Article 1053 Weibo Article 1054 Weibo Article 1055 Weibo Article 1056 Weibo Article 1057 Weibo Article 1058 Weibo Article 1059 Weibo Article 1060 Weibo Article 1061 Weibo Article 1062 Weibo Article 1063 Weibo Article 1064 Weibo Article 1065 Weibo Article 1066 Weibo Article 1067 Weibo Article 1068 Weibo Article 1069 Weibo Article 1070 Weibo Article 1071 Weibo Article 1072 Weibo Article 1073 Weibo Article 1074 Weibo Article 1075 Weibo Article 1076 Weibo Article 1077 Weibo Article 1078 Weibo Article 1079 Weibo Article 1080 Weibo Article 1081 Weibo Article 1082 Weibo Article 1083 Weibo Article 1084 Weibo Article 1085 Weibo Article 1086 Weibo Article 1087 Weibo Article 1088 Weibo Article 1089 Weibo Article 1090 Weibo Article 1091 Weibo Article 1092 Weibo Article 1093 Weibo Article 1094 Weibo Article 1095 Weibo Article 1096 Weibo Article 1097 Weibo Article 1098 Weibo Article 1099 Weibo Article 1100 Weibo Article 1101 Weibo Article 1102 Weibo Article 1103 Weibo Article 1104 Weibo Article 1105 Weibo Article 1106 Weibo Article 1107 Weibo Article 1108 Weibo Article 1109 Weibo Article 1110 Weibo Article 1111 Weibo Article 1112 Weibo Article 1113 Weibo Article 1114 Weibo Article 1115 Weibo Article 1116 Weibo Article 1117 Weibo Article 1118 Weibo Article 1119 Weibo Article 1120 Weibo Article 1121 Weibo Article 1122 Weibo Article 1123 Weibo Article 1124 Weibo Article 1125 Weibo Article 1126 Weibo Article 1127 Weibo Article 1128 Weibo Article 1129 Weibo Article 1130 Weibo Article 1131 Weibo Article 1132 Weibo Article 1133 Weibo Article 1134 Weibo Article 1135 Weibo Article 1136 Weibo Article 1137 Weibo Article 1138 Weibo Article 1139 Weibo Article 1140 Weibo Article 1141 Weibo Article 1142 Weibo Article 1143 Weibo Article 1144 Weibo Article 1145 Weibo Article 1146 Weibo Article 1147 Weibo Article 1148 Weibo Article 1149 Weibo Article 1150 Weibo Article 1151 Weibo Article 1152 Weibo Article 1153 Weibo Article 1154 Weibo Article 1155 Weibo Article 1156 Weibo Article 1157 Weibo Article 1158 Weibo Article 1159 Weibo Article 1160 Weibo Article 1161 Weibo Article 1162 Weibo Article 1163 Weibo Article 1164 Weibo Article 1165 Weibo Article 1166 Weibo Article 1167 Weibo Article 1168 Weibo Article 1169 Weibo Article 1170 Weibo Article 1171 Weibo Article 1172 Weibo Article 1173 Weibo Article 1174 Weibo Article 1175 Weibo Article 1176 Weibo Article 1177 Weibo Article 1178 Weibo Article 1179 Weibo Article 1180 Weibo Article 1181 Weibo Article 1182 Weibo Article 1183 Weibo Article 1184 Weibo Article 1185 Weibo Article 1186 Weibo Article 1187 Weibo Article 1188 Weibo Article 1189 Weibo Article 1190 Weibo Article 1191 Weibo Article 1192 Weibo Article 1193 Weibo Article 1194 Weibo Article 1195 Weibo Article 1196 Weibo Article 1197 Weibo Article 1198 Weibo Article 1199 Weibo Article 1200 Weibo Article 1201 Weibo Article 1202 Weibo Article 1203 Weibo Article 1204 Weibo Article 1205 Weibo Article 1206 Weibo Article 1207 Weibo Article 1208 Weibo Article 1209 Weibo Article 1210 Weibo Article 1211 Weibo Article 1212 Weibo Article 1213 Weibo Article 1214 Weibo Article 1215 Weibo Article 1216 Weibo Article 1217 Weibo Article 1218 Weibo Article 1219 Weibo Article 1220 Weibo Article 1221 Weibo Article 1222 Weibo Article 1223 Weibo Article 1224 Weibo Article 1225 Weibo Article 1226 Weibo Article 1227 Weibo Article 1228 Weibo Article 1229 Weibo Article 1230 Weibo Article 1231 Weibo Article 1232 Weibo Article 1233 Weibo Article 1234 Weibo Article 1235 Weibo Article 1236 Weibo Article 1237 Weibo Article 1238 Weibo Article 1239 Weibo Article 1240 Weibo Article 1241 Weibo Article 1242 Weibo Article 1243 Weibo Article 1244 Weibo Article 1245 Weibo Article 1246 Weibo Article 1247 Weibo Article 1248 Weibo Article 1249 Weibo Article 1250 Weibo Article 1251 Weibo Article 1252 Weibo Article 1253 Weibo Article 1254 Weibo Article 1255 Weibo Article 1256 Weibo Article 1257 Weibo Article 1258 Weibo Article 1259 Weibo Article 1260 Weibo Article 1261 Weibo Article 1262 Weibo Article 1263 Weibo Article 1264 Weibo Article 1265 Weibo Article 1266 Weibo Article 1267 Weibo Article 1268 Weibo Article 1269 Weibo Article 1270 Weibo Article 1271 Weibo Article 1272 Weibo Article 1273 Weibo Article 1274 Weibo Article 1275 Weibo Article 1276 Weibo Article 1277 Weibo Article 1278 Weibo Article 1279 Weibo Article 1280 Weibo Article 1281 Weibo Article 1282 Weibo Article 1283 Weibo Article 1284 Weibo Article 1285 Weibo Article 1286 Weibo Article 1287 Weibo Article 1288 Weibo Article 1289 Weibo Article 1290 Weibo Article 1291 Weibo Article 1292 Weibo Article 1293 Weibo Article 1294 Weibo Article 1295 Weibo Article 1296 Weibo Article 1297 Weibo Article 1298 Weibo Article 1299 Weibo Article 1300 Weibo Article 1301 Weibo Article 1302 Weibo Article 1303 Weibo Article 1304 Weibo Article 1305 Weibo Article 1306 Weibo Article 1307 Weibo Article 1308 Weibo Article 1309 Weibo Article 1310 Weibo Article 1311 Weibo Article 1312 Weibo Article 1313 Weibo Article 1314 Weibo Article 1315 Weibo Article 1316 Weibo Article 1317 Weibo Article 1318 Weibo Article 1319 Weibo Article 1320 Weibo Article 1321 Weibo Article 1322 Weibo Article 1323 Weibo Article 1324 Weibo Article 1325 Weibo Article 1326 Weibo Article 1327 Weibo Article 1328 Weibo Article 1329 Weibo Article 1330 Weibo Article 1331 Weibo Article 1332 Weibo Article 1333 Weibo Article 1334 Weibo Article 1335 Weibo Article 1336 Weibo Article 1337 Weibo Article 1338 Weibo Article 1339 Weibo Article 1340 Weibo Article 1341 Weibo Article 1342 Weibo Article 1343 Weibo Article 1344 Weibo Article 1345 Weibo Article 1346 Weibo Article 1347 Weibo Article 1348 Weibo Article 1349 Weibo Article 1350 Weibo Article 1351 Weibo Article 1352 Weibo Article 1353 Weibo Article 1354 Weibo Article 1355 Weibo Article 1356 Weibo Article 1357 Weibo Article 1358 Weibo Article 1359 Weibo Article 1360 Weibo Article 1361 Weibo Article 1362 Weibo Article 1363 Weibo Article 1364 Weibo Article 1365 Weibo Article 1366 Weibo Article 1367 Weibo Article 1368 Weibo Article 1369 Weibo Article 1370 Weibo Article 1371 Weibo Article 1372 Weibo Article 1373 Weibo Article 1374 Weibo Article 1375 Weibo Article 1376 Weibo Article 1377 Weibo Article 1378 Weibo Article 1379 Weibo Article 1380 Weibo Article 1381 Weibo Article 1382 Weibo Article 1383 Weibo Article 1384 Weibo Article 1385 Weibo Article 1386 Weibo Article 1387 Weibo Article 1388 Weibo Article 1389 Weibo Article 1390 Weibo Article 1391 Weibo Article 1392 Weibo Article 1393 Weibo Article 1394 Weibo Article 1395 Weibo Article 1396 Weibo Article 1397 Weibo Article 1398 Weibo Article 1399 Weibo Article 1400 Weibo Article 1401 Weibo Article 1402 Weibo Article 1403 Weibo Article 1404 Weibo Article 1405 Weibo Article 1406 Weibo Article 1407 Weibo Article 1408 Weibo Article 1409 Weibo Article 1410 Weibo Article 1411 Weibo Article 1412 Weibo Article 1413 Weibo Article 1414 Weibo Article 1415 Weibo Article 1416 Weibo Article 1417 Weibo Article 1418 Weibo Article 1419 Weibo Article 1420 Weibo Article 1421 Weibo Article 1422 Weibo Article 1423 Weibo Article 1424 Weibo Article 1425 Weibo Article 1426 Weibo Article 1427 Weibo Article 1428 Weibo Article 1429 Weibo Article 1430 Weibo Article 1431 Weibo Article 1432 Weibo Article 1433 Weibo Article 1434 Weibo Article 1435 Weibo Article 1436 Weibo Article 1437 Weibo Article 1438 Weibo Article 1439 Weibo Article 1440 Weibo Article 1441 Weibo Article 1442 Weibo Article 1443 Weibo Article 1444 Weibo Article 1445 Weibo Article 1446 Weibo Article 1447 Weibo Article 1448 Weibo Article 1449 Weibo Article 1450 Weibo Article 1451 Weibo Article 1452 Weibo Article 1453 Weibo Article 1454